Chudleigh Town Council
Chudleigh Town Hall, Market Way, Chudleigh, Devon TQ13 0HL
Email: clerk@chudleigh-tc.gov.uk / Telephone: 01626 853 140
Opening Hours: Monday - Friday 9:00 - 15:00

TEIGNBRIDGE DISTRICT COUNCIL APPLICATIONS RECEIVED WEEK ENDING 8th APRIL 2016

TEIGNBRIDGE DISTRICT COUNCIL

APPLICATIONS RECEIVED WEEK ENDING 8 APRIL 2016

Copies of the applications and plans listed below are available for public inspection from 8.30 am to 5.00pm Monday to Friday (4.30pm Fridays) from reception at Teignbridge District Council, Forde House, Newton Abbot, TQ12 4XX. To view documents online, click on the link provided with each application, then click on the Associated Documents button on the left of the screen. Alternatively go to www.teignbridge.gov.uk/planningonline

Comments about the proposals can be made in writing to Development Management, Forde House, Newton Abbot, Devon, TQ12 4XX, by e-mail to planning@teignbridge.gov.uk or via the Submit Comments button when viewing application details on the website. Please note that any comments cannot be treated as confidential and will be published on the internet for general viewing. Only planning matters can be considered and comments which the Council considers to be inappropriate may be removed from letters. Please see our website for advice on what constitutes a planning matter. Comments will not be acknowledged. Once the application is determined, the Decision Notice will be displayed on the website or a copy can be sent on request if an SAE is provided.

Key to Decision Level – DEL –DELEGATED DECISION – BY OFFICER

COMM – COMMITTEE DECISION

PARISH: NEWTON ABBOT WARD: Bushell
APPLICATION REF: 16/00917/FUL OFFICER: Nicola Turner
DECISION LEVEL: DEL
LOCATION: Thame House Rundle Road
PROPOSAL: Partial demolition of outbuildings and creation of new dwelling
APPLICANT Mr G Attwood West Hele Bovey Tracey Devon TQ13 9PP
AGENT: Whickham Architecture Ltd FAO Mr M Yeo Rock House Lower Meadow Rise Dawlish Devon EX7 9BX
Web Link: http://gis.teignbridge.gov.uk/TeignbridgePlanningOnline/Results.aspx?Type=Application&Refval=16/00917/FUL&MN=Y
PARISH: NEWTON ABBOT WARD: Bushell
APPLICATION REF: 16/00923/ADV OFFICER: Nicola Turner
DECISION LEVEL: DEL
LOCATION: Asda Supermarket Highweek Street
PROPOSAL: Two illuminated canopy fascia signs, two canopy fascia signs, four disc signs, one totem sign and two banner frame signs
APPLICANT Asda Supermarket Highweek Street Newton Abbot Devon TQ12 1TG
AGENT: Mr C Ruddock Bowman Riley Architects Wellington House Otley Street Skipton Yorks BD23 1EL
Web Link: http://gis.teignbridge.gov.uk/TeignbridgePlanningOnline/Results.aspx?Type=Application&Refval=16/00923/ADV&MN=Y
PARISH: NEWTON ABBOT WARD: Bradley
APPLICATION REF: 16/00965/FUL OFFICER: Nicola Turner
DECISION LEVEL: DEL
LOCATION: 1A Belvedere Road
PROPOSAL: Conservatory to west elevation
APPLICANT Mr J Wilson 1A Belvedere Road Newton Abbot Devon TQ12 1QJ
AGENT: Mr R Papworth Paul & Papworth 3 Hoopers Close Landrake Saltash Cornwall PL12 5DN
Web Link: http://gis.teignbridge.gov.uk/TeignbridgePlanningOnline/Results.aspx?Type=Application&Refval=16/00965/FUL&MN=Y
PARISH: NEWTON ABBOT WARD: Buckland and Milber
APPLICATION REF: 16/00977/TPO OFFICER: Mark Waddams
DECISION LEVEL: DEL
LOCATION: 10 Ridgeway Road
PROPOSAL: Crown lift one pine tree with pruning and removal of dead wood
APPLICANT Mrs Wale 10 Ridgeway Road Newton Abbot Devon TQ12 4LS
AGENT: Mr Wojciech Rosinke 1 Lisburn Crescent Higher Woodfield Road Torquay Devon TQ1 2LA
Web Link: http://gis.teignbridge.gov.uk/TeignbridgePlanningOnline/Results.aspx?Type=Application&Refval=16/00977/TPO&MN=Y
PARISH: BOVEY TRACEY WARD: Bovey
APPLICATION REF: 16/00134/FUL OFFICER: Nicola Turner
DECISION LEVEL: DEL
LOCATION: 1-2 Town Hall Place
PROPOSAL: Alterations to front elevation including formation of parking, new ground floor arrangement, and new windows to first floor
APPLICANT Mr P Bradford 1-2 Town Hall Place Bovey Tracey Devon TQ13 9EQ
AGENT: Chris Baker CB Design 18 Reynell Avenue Newton Abbot Devon TQ12 4HE
Web Link: http://gis.teignbridge.gov.uk/TeignbridgePlanningOnline/Results.aspx?Type=Application&Refval=16/00134/FUL&MN=Y
PARISH: BOVEY TRACEY WARD: Bovey
APPLICATION REF: 16/00924/TPO OFFICER: Mark Waddams
DECISION LEVEL: DEL
LOCATION: Monterey Park Newton Road
PROPOSAL: Coppice one ash, remove one willow, crown lift one Douglas fir and prune overhanging vegetation as indicated on the accompanying plan
APPLICANT Remus Management Ltd
AGENT: Mr Paddy Faircloth Free Range Forestry Oak Wood Farm Sidmouth Road Aylesbeare Devon EX5 2JW
Web Link: http://gis.teignbridge.gov.uk/TeignbridgePlanningOnline/Results.aspx?Type=Application&Refval=16/00924/TPO&MN=Y
PARISH: OGWELL WARD: Ambrook
APPLICATION REF: 16/00975/FUL OFFICER: Nicola Turner
DECISION LEVEL: DEL
LOCATION: 3 Brownings Walk
PROPOSAL: New window at first floor on south west elevation
APPLICANT Mr & Mrs Newman 3 Brownings Walk Ogwell Devon TQ12 6YR
Web Link: http://gis.teignbridge.gov.uk/TeignbridgePlanningOnline/Results.aspx?Type=Application&Refval=16/00975/FUL&MN=Y
PARISH: KINGSTEIGNTON WARD: Kingsteignton East
APPLICATION REF: 16/00690/FUL OFFICER: Eve Somerville
DECISION LEVEL: DEL
LOCATION: Great Hill Hestow Road
PROPOSAL: Extensions and alterations
APPLICANT Mr M Wills Great Hill Hestow Road Kingsteignton Devon TQ12 3QB
AGENT: AT Design 69 Wilton Way Abbotskerswell Devon TQ12 5PG
Web Link: http://gis.teignbridge.gov.uk/TeignbridgePlanningOnline/Results.aspx?Type=Application&Refval=16/00690/FUL&MN=Y
PARISH: KINGSTEIGNTON WARD: Kingsteignton East
APPLICATION REF: 16/00876/FUL OFFICER: Eve Somerville
DECISION LEVEL: DEL
LOCATION: 9 Stones Close
PROPOSAL: First floor extension and rear porch
APPLICANT Mr D Morris 9 Stones Close Kingsteignton Devon TQ12 3YY
AGENT: Mr J Dawson JD Architectural Design Bank Chambers 1 Vaughan Parade Torquay Devon TQ2 5EG
Web Link: http://gis.teignbridge.gov.uk/TeignbridgePlanningOnline/Results.aspx?Type=Application&Refval=16/00876/FUL&MN=Y
PARISH: KINGSTEIGNTON WARD: Kingsteignton East
APPLICATION REF: 16/00945/FUL OFFICER: Eve Somerville
DECISION LEVEL: DEL
LOCATION: 11 St Columba Close
PROPOSAL: Two storey side extension
APPLICANT Mr & Mrs Thayre 11 St Columba Close Kingsteignton Devon TQ12 3RL
AGENT: C B Design 18 Reynell Avenue Newton Abbot Devon TQ12 4HE
Web Link: http://gis.teignbridge.gov.uk/TeignbridgePlanningOnline/Results.aspx?Type=Application&Refval=16/00945/FUL&MN=Y
PARISH: BISHOPSTEIGNTON WARD: Bishopsteignton
APPLICATION REF: 16/00794/FUL OFFICER: Nicola Turner
DECISION LEVEL: DEL
LOCATION: West Lodge Lindridge
PROPOSAL: Provision of garden studio
APPLICANT Mr N Dagworthy West Lodge Lindridge Teignmouth Devon TQ14 9TG
AGENT: Mr R Fraser Higher Lodge Luscombe Hill Dawlish Devon EX7 0PX
Web Link: http://gis.teignbridge.gov.uk/TeignbridgePlanningOnline/Results.aspx?Type=Application&Refval=16/00794/FUL&MN=Y
PARISH: BISHOPSTEIGNTON WARD: Bishopsteignton
APPLICATION REF: 16/00964/FUL OFFICER: Nicola Turner
DECISION LEVEL: DEL
LOCATION: 28 Orchard View Wear Farm
PROPOSAL: Conservatory to rear
APPLICANT Mrs Young 28 Orchard View Wear Farm Newton Road Bishopsteignton Devon TQ14 9PU
AGENT: Mr R Papworth Paul & Papworth 3 Hoopers Close Landrake Saltash Cornwall PL12 5DN
Web Link: http://gis.teignbridge.gov.uk/TeignbridgePlanningOnline/Results.aspx?Type=Application&Refval=16/00964/FUL&MN=Y
PARISH: BISHOPSTEIGNTON WARD: Bishopsteignton
APPLICATION REF: 16/00979/FUL OFFICER: Anna Mooney
DECISION LEVEL: DEL
LOCATION: 18 Horns Park
PROPOSAL: Single storey rear extension with external canopy linking to existing detached garden room
APPLICANT Mrs V Roberts 18 Horns Park Bishopsteignton Devon TQ14 9RP
AGENT: Richard Partington Architect 6 Oaks Drive Four Oaks Sutton Coldfield West Midlands B75 5AP
Web Link: http://gis.teignbridge.gov.uk/TeignbridgePlanningOnline/Results.aspx?Type=Application&Refval=16/00979/FUL&MN=Y
PARISH: TEIGNMOUTH WARD: Teignmouth East
APPLICATION REF: 16/00828/FUL OFFICER: Anna Mooney
DECISION LEVEL: DEL
LOCATION: Land to rear of Teignmouth Pavilions Den Crescent
PROPOSAL: Provision of a raised table top within the Upper Den carriageway including a level pedestrian access ramp and external steps between the Promenade and the Pavilions
APPLICANT Mr P Briscoe Teignbridge District Council Forde House Newton Abbot Devon TQ12 4XX
Web Link: http://gis.teignbridge.gov.uk/TeignbridgePlanningOnline/Results.aspx?Type=Application&Refval=16/00828/FUL&MN=Y
PARISH: TEIGNMOUTH WARD: Teignmouth East
APPLICATION REF: 16/00853/FUL OFFICER: Nicola Turner
DECISION LEVEL: DEL
LOCATION: 10 Somerset Place
PROPOSAL: Air conditioning unit
APPLICANT Mrs J Athey 21 Fordens Lane Holcombe Dawlish Devon EX7 0LD
Web Link: http://gis.teignbridge.gov.uk/TeignbridgePlanningOnline/Results.aspx?Type=Application&Refval=16/00853/FUL&MN=Y
PARISH: TEIGNMOUTH WARD: Teignmouth East
APPLICATION REF: 16/00866/FUL OFFICER: Angharad Williams
DECISION LEVEL: DEL
LOCATION: Cross Park New Road
PROPOSAL: Division of property into two residential units
APPLICANT Mr J Bailey Cross Park New Road Teignmouth Devon TQ14 8UJ
Web Link: http://gis.teignbridge.gov.uk/TeignbridgePlanningOnline/Results.aspx?Type=Application&Refval=16/00866/FUL&MN=Y
PARISH: TEIGNMOUTH WARD: Teignmouth West
APPLICATION REF: 16/00909/FUL OFFICER: Jacqueline Houslander
DECISION LEVEL: DEL
LOCATION: 147 Coombe Vale Road
PROPOSAL: First floor rear extension
APPLICANT Mr & Mrs Vaughan 147 Coombe Vale Road Teignmouth Devon TQ14 9ER
AGENT: Mr S Epps Westcountry Custom Homes The Old Nursery Gabwell Stokeinteignhead Devon TQ12 4QR
Web Link: http://gis.teignbridge.gov.uk/TeignbridgePlanningOnline/Results.aspx?Type=Application&Refval=16/00909/FUL&MN=Y
PARISH: TEIGNMOUTH WARD: Teignmouth East
APPLICATION REF: 16/00914/FUL OFFICER: Jacqueline Houslander
DECISION LEVEL: DEL
LOCATION: 9 Higher Woodway Road
PROPOSAL: Single storey side and two storey rear extensions
APPLICANT Mr J Dykes 23 Smith Hill Bishopsteignton Devon TQ14 9QT
Web Link: http://gis.teignbridge.gov.uk/TeignbridgePlanningOnline/Results.aspx?Type=Application&Refval=16/00914/FUL&MN=Y
PARISH: TEIGNMOUTH WARD: Teignmouth East
APPLICATION REF: 16/00934/FUL OFFICER: Anna Mooney
DECISION LEVEL: DEL
LOCATION: 7 Hazel Close
PROPOSAL: Single storey rear extension
APPLICANT Mr M Boyer 7 Hazel Close Teignmouth Devon TQ14 8RN
Web Link: http://gis.teignbridge.gov.uk/TeignbridgePlanningOnline/Results.aspx?Type=Application&Refval=16/00934/FUL&MN=Y
PARISH: TEIGNMOUTH WARD: Teignmouth Central
APPLICATION REF: 16/00944/VAR OFFICER: Anna Mooney
DECISION LEVEL: DEL
LOCATION: Teignmouth Community College Exeter Road
PROPOSAL: Variation of condition 2 on planning permission 15/01775/FUL to amend player entrance area and goal storage areas
APPLICANT Mr D Coppard Teignmouth Community College Exeter Road Teignmouth Devon TQ14 9HZ
AGENT: Mr T Betts Surface Standards Ltd 1A Perth House Corbygate Business Park Corby Northants NN17 5JG
Web Link: http://gis.teignbridge.gov.uk/TeignbridgePlanningOnline/Results.aspx?Type=Application&Refval=16/00944/VAR&MN=Y
PARISH: TEIGNMOUTH WARD: Teignmouth East
APPLICATION REF: 16/01015/TPO OFFICER: Mark Waddams
DECISION LEVEL: DEL
LOCATION: 4 St Scholasticas Dawlish Road
PROPOSAL: Fell one diseased beech tree and prune one yew tree
APPLICANT Mrs Carole Jackson Flat 3 Dolphin Court Powderham Terrace Teignmouth Devon TQ14 8BL
AGENT: Mr John Sherwin Rokeby New Road Teignmouth Devon TQ14 8UF
Web Link: http://gis.teignbridge.gov.uk/TeignbridgePlanningOnline/Results.aspx?Type=Application&Refval=16/01015/TPO&MN=Y
PARISH: DAWLISH WARD: Dawlish Central and North East
APPLICATION REF: 16/00307/FUL OFFICER: Eve Somerville
DECISION LEVEL: DEL
LOCATION: 4 Haldon Terrace
PROPOSAL: Change of use from 4 self-contained flats and owner's accommodation into 1 dwelling and annexe
APPLICANT Mr G Reilly 27 Broadgate Road Kingskerswell Devon TQ12 5DB
AGENT: Darren Law Architecture 81 Steed Close Paignton Devon TQ4 7SP
Web Link: http://gis.teignbridge.gov.uk/TeignbridgePlanningOnline/Results.aspx?Type=Application&Refval=16/00307/FUL&MN=Y
PARISH: DAWLISH WARD: Dawlish Central and North East
APPLICATION REF: 16/00308/LBC OFFICER: Eve Somerville
DECISION LEVEL: DEL
LOCATION: 4 Haldon Terrace
PROPOSAL: Change of use from 4 self-contained flats and owner's accommodation into 1 dwelling and annexe
APPLICANT Mr G Reilly 27 Broadgate Road Kingskerswell Devon TQ12 5DB
AGENT: Darren Law Architecture 81 Steed Close Paignton Devon TQ4 7SP
Web Link: http://gis.teignbridge.gov.uk/TeignbridgePlanningOnline/Results.aspx?Type=Application&Refval=16/00308/LBC&MN=Y
PARISH: DAWLISH WARD: Dawlish Central and North East
APPLICATION REF: 16/00565/COU OFFICER: Nicola Turner
DECISION LEVEL: DEL
LOCATION: Oakleigh Shutterton Lane
PROPOSAL: Change of use and extension of ancillary garage and office to two supported living units
APPLICANT Pontesial Ltd Oakleigh Shutterton Lane Dawlish Warren Devon EX7 0PD
AGENT: Mr P A Sheldon J & P Sheldon Commerce House Dawlish Business Park Exeter Road Dawlish Devon EX7 0NH
Web Link: http://gis.teignbridge.gov.uk/TeignbridgePlanningOnline/Results.aspx?Type=Application&Refval=16/00565/COU&MN=Y
PARISH: DAWLISH WARD: Dawlish Central and North East
APPLICATION REF: 16/00852/FUL OFFICER: Estelle Smith
DECISION LEVEL: DEL
LOCATION: Cofton Country Holiday Park Cofton
PROPOSAL: Demolition of existing agricultural barn and construction of new ablutions block with shower/toilet facilities and staff accommodation
APPLICANT Mr C Jeffrey Cofton Country Holidays Ltd Cofton Country Holiday Park Cofton Starcross Devon EX6 8RP
AGENT: Mr G Elliott Lacey Hickie & Caley Ltd The Design Studio Emperor Way Exeter Devon EX1 3QS
Web Link: http://gis.teignbridge.gov.uk/TeignbridgePlanningOnline/Results.aspx?Type=Application&Refval=16/00852/FUL&MN=Y
PARISH: DAWLISH WARD: Dawlish Central and North East
APPLICATION REF: 16/00916/FUL OFFICER: Estelle Smith
DECISION LEVEL: DEL
LOCATION: Cofton Country Holiday Park Cofton
PROPOSAL: Provision of five staff caravans and parking
APPLICANT Mr C Jeffrey Cofton Country Holidays Ltd Cofton Country Holiday Park Cofton Starcross Devon EX6 8RP
AGENT: Mr G Elliott Lacey, Hickie & Caley Ltd The Design Studio Emperor Way Exeter Devon EX1 3QS
Web Link: http://gis.teignbridge.gov.uk/TeignbridgePlanningOnline/Results.aspx?Type=Application&Refval=16/00916/FUL&MN=Y
PARISH: DAWLISH WARD: Dawlish South West
APPLICATION REF: 16/00938/FUL OFFICER: Eve Somerville
DECISION LEVEL: DEL
LOCATION: 20 Sweetbriar Lane Holcombe
PROPOSAL: Pitched roof over existing garage and store to include extension and conversion to habitable accommodation
APPLICANT Mr P Wilson 20 Sweetbriar Lane Holcombe Dawlish Devon EX7 0JZ
AGENT: Mr D Francis DCF Planning & Design Lulwind 88 Dawlish Road Teignmouth Devon TQ14 8TG
Web Link: http://gis.teignbridge.gov.uk/TeignbridgePlanningOnline/Results.aspx?Type=Application&Refval=16/00938/FUL&MN=Y
PARISH: CHUDLEIGH WARD: Chudleigh
APPLICATION REF: 16/00548/TPO OFFICER: Mark Waddams
DECISION LEVEL: DEL
LOCATION: Old Chapel Exeter Road
PROPOSAL: Prune one willow and one ash
APPLICANT Mr John Rattlidge The Old Chapel Exeter Road Kingsteignton Devon TQ13 0DD
AGENT: Mr David Brown Brown Contractors 16 Haldon View Chudleigh Devon TQ13 0LN
Web Link: http://gis.teignbridge.gov.uk/TeignbridgePlanningOnline/Results.aspx?Type=Application&Refval=16/00548/TPO&MN=Y
PARISH: CHUDLEIGH WARD: Chudleigh
APPLICATION REF: 16/00839/NPA OFFICER: Eve Somerville
DECISION LEVEL: DEL
LOCATION: Woodlands Farm
PROPOSAL: Application for Prior Approval under Part 3 Class Q (a) and (b) and paragraph W of the GPDO for change of use of a barn from agricultural use to a dwelling
APPLICANT Mr G Gill Woodlands Farm Chudleigh Newton Abbot Devon TQ12 0NE
AGENT: Mr S Anderson 1 Lea Vale Road Newton Abbot Devon TQ12 1SG
Web Link: http://gis.teignbridge.gov.uk/TeignbridgePlanningOnline/Results.aspx?Type=Application&Refval=16/00839/NPA&MN=Y
PARISH: SHILLINGFORD WARD: Kenn Valley
APPLICATION REF: 16/00817/FUL OFFICER: Anna Mooney
DECISION LEVEL: DEL
LOCATION: Mistletoe Cottage Shillingford St George
PROPOSAL: Porch to east elevation
APPLICANT Mr T Clarke Mistletoe Cottage Shillingford St George Devon EX2 9UU
Web Link: http://gis.teignbridge.gov.uk/TeignbridgePlanningOnline/Results.aspx?Type=Application&Refval=16/00817/FUL&MN=Y
PARISH: TEDBURN ST MARY WARD: Teignbridge North
APPLICATION REF: 16/00907/FUL OFFICER: Anna Mooney
DECISION LEVEL: DEL
LOCATION: Land at Floyte Lane Six Mile Hill
PROPOSAL: Agricultural building
APPLICANT Mr S Taylor North Park Cottage Tedburn St Mary Devon EX6 6DW
AGENT: Mr G Cawse Cawse Design Summerfield Exeter Street North Tawton Devon EX20 2HB
Web Link: http://gis.teignbridge.gov.uk/TeignbridgePlanningOnline/Results.aspx?Type=Application&Refval=16/00907/FUL&MN=Y
PARISH: ABBOTSKERSWELL WARD: Ambrook
APPLICATION REF: 16/00801/FUL OFFICER: Helen Murdoch
DECISION LEVEL: DEL
LOCATION: Land at NGR 285048 69125 Totnes Road
PROPOSAL: Creation of track
APPLICANT Mr R Downs 18 Nelson Road Brixham Devon
AGENT: Mr P Bradfield Bradfield Rutledge Associates 33 Maple Road Brixham Devon TQ5 0DG
Web Link: http://gis.teignbridge.gov.uk/TeignbridgePlanningOnline/Results.aspx?Type=Application&Refval=16/00801/FUL&MN=Y

YOU MAY MAKE OBSERVATIONS UPON THIS NOTIFICATION

PARISH: ASHCOMBE WARD: Kenton with Starcross
APPLICATION REF: 16/00760/AGR OFFICER: Jacqueline Houslander
DECISION LEVEL: DEL
LOCATION: Forestry Yard Ashcombe
PROPOSAL: Extension to existing forestry yard
APPLICANT Mr R Rayner Ashcombe Estate The Old Rectory Ashcombe Dawlish Devon EX7 0QD
Web Link: http://gis.teignbridge.gov.uk/TeignbridgePlanningOnline/Results.aspx?Type=Application&Refval=16/00760/AGR&MN=Y
TEIGNBRIDGE DISTRICT COUNCIL
APPLICATIONS RECEIVED WEEK ENDING 8 APRIL 2016

Applications with Amended Description during current week:

PARISH: DAWLISH WARD: Dawlish South West
APPLICATION REF: 16/00765/LBC OFFICER: Donna Crabtree
DECISION LEVEL: DEL
LOCATION: 13 Weech Road
PROPOSAL: Demolition of building
APPLICANT: Mr J Farrell 5th Floor One American Square 15 Crosswell London EC3N 2SG
AGENT: Mr S Christmas Narracotts Architects 2 Montpellier Terrace Torquay Devon TQ1 1BL
Web Link: http://gis.teignbridge.gov.uk/TeignbridgePlanningOnline/Results.aspx?Type=Application&Refval=16/00765/LBC&MN=Y

Appeals Received during this week:

PARISH: SHALDON WARD: Shaldon and Stokeinteignhead
APPEAL REF: 16/00025/REF OFFICER: Christine Bolton
APPEAL TYPE: Written Representations
LOCATION: Land at NGR 293531 71765 Picket Head Hill
DESCRIPTION: Appeal against refusal of planning permission 15/02241/FUL - Erection of a detached dwelling
APPELLANT: Mr R Thompson King Street Richmond Surrey TW9 1ND
AGENT: Mr Spencer Copping Europe House Bancroft Road Reigate Surrey
Web Link http://gis.teignbridge.gov.uk/TeignbridgePlanningOnline/Results.aspx?Type=Appeal&Refval=16/00025/REF&MN=Y